Language Selection

Get healthy now with MedBeds!
Click here to book your session

Protect your whole family with Orgo-Life® Quantum MedBed Energy Technology® devices.

Advertising by Adpathway

         

 Advertising by Adpathway

Culling Seals and Sea Lions Won't Bring Back West Coast Salmon, Science Study Finds

2 hours ago 4

PROTECT YOUR DNA WITH QUANTUM TECHNOLOGY

Orgo-Life the new way to the future

  Advertising by Adpathway

Killing large numbers of seals, sea lions and seabirds along the U.S. West Coast would do little or nothing to help struggling salmon, according to a study published on 19 November in Science. The researchers, from NOAA Fisheries and Oregon State University, built an ecosystem model covering the ocean off Northern California, Oregon and Washington. They found that widespread predator reductions brought little or no net benefit for Chinook and coho salmon.

The reason, the study's release explains, lies in the food web. Seals and sea lions do eat salmon, but they also eat Pacific hake and other fish that themselves eat young salmon or compete with them for food. Remove the marine mammals, and those other fish increase, cancelling out much of the gain.

The finding lands in the middle of a live political debate. Lawmakers and some fishing and tribal groups in the U.S. and Canada have called for wider culls of seals and sea lions to help salmon recover.

What the Study Did

The paper, titled "Widespread marine mammal and seabird reductions are unlikely to benefit salmon due to indirect ecosystem effects" (DOI 10.1126/science.aeb1122), uses a computer model of the regional marine ecosystem. Instead of looking only at how many salmon predators eat, it tracks who eats whom across the whole food web.

That distinction matters. Simple calculations can make culls look attractive: if a seal population eats a certain number of salmon each year, removing some seals should leave more salmon. But predators rarely affect only one species. In a food web, removing one predator changes the numbers of many other animals, and those changes ripple back.

In this case, the model showed that California sea lions, Steller sea lions, harbour seals and seabirds also keep in check the fish that prey on or compete with juvenile salmon. Lead author Dylan Gomes and co-author Josh Stewart discussed the results with the Statesman Journal, which reported that broad reductions of these predators produced little or no net benefit for salmon in the model.

The Hake Connection

Pacific hake is one of the most abundant fish off the West Coast and supports a large commercial fishery. Hake also eat smaller fish, including young salmon in their first months at sea.

Sea lions eat a lot of hake. According to the researchers, that means sea lions indirectly protect some young salmon by keeping hake numbers down. A cull that reduced sea lions could therefore let hake increase, and more hake could eat more young salmon.

This kind of chain is often called an "indirect effect". It is one reason ecologists warn against judging a predator only by what it eats.

Where Targeted Removals May Still Help

The study does not say predators never matter. The release and the newspaper report both note that targeted removals at specific bottlenecks, such as dams or fish ladders where salmon are crowded and easy to catch, can still help local runs.

The Statesman Journal points to Willamette Falls in Oregon, where removing sea lions that gathered to feed on migrating fish helped protect a local steelhead run. The difference is scale. Removing a handful of individuals that exploit a pinch point is very different from reducing whole populations across thousands of kilometres of coast.

A Long History of Culls

Killing seals and sea lions to protect fish is not a new idea. In British Columbia, the David Suzuki Foundation notes that 114,903 harbour seals and 49,100 sea lions were reported killed under a federal culling programme that ran from 1918 to 1968. That programme ended decades ago, and seal populations have since recovered.

In the United States, culling continues on a small, targeted scale. The Wildlife Society describes how California sea lions are captured at Bonneville Dam on the Columbia River by state and federal staff and euthanised off site. These removals focus on individual animals that feed on fish crowded below the dam.

Calls for much broader culls have grown in recent years, especially in British Columbia, where some First Nations-led groups have asked for permission to harvest seals and sea lions. The new study speaks directly to that debate. It does not test the cultural or food-security arguments for a harvest, but it does question the claim that fewer marine mammals would mean more salmon.

Why Salmon Are Struggling

Many Chinook and coho populations on the West Coast are listed as threatened or endangered under the U.S. Endangered Species Act. Seals and sea lions, meanwhile, have recovered strongly since the Marine Mammal Protection Act of 1972 ended most hunting. Their rising numbers have made them an easy target for blame.

But salmon face many pressures throughout their lives. These include dams that block rivers, loss of spawning habitat, warmer water, changing ocean conditions and fishing. NOAA Fisheries' project page on the ecosystem model frames it as a tool for comparing these management choices side by side.

Limits of the Study

This is a modelling study, not a field experiment. No animals were removed to test the prediction. Models depend on the data and assumptions put into them, including diet estimates and population sizes, and those carry uncertainty.

The study also covers one region of the Pacific coast. Food webs differ elsewhere, such as in British Columbia's Salish Sea, so the result cannot simply be applied to every salmon river. And the paper has not yet drawn published responses from fishing groups or tribal nations that support culls. Their views will matter as policymakers weigh the findings.

What Comes Next

The study gives managers a way to test ideas before acting on them. For anyone hoping that culling marine mammals offers a quick fix for salmon, the model's message is sobering. In an ocean food web, the enemy of your enemy may be your friend.

The bigger question is where limited money and effort should go. The researchers' results suggest that habitat, river conditions and targeted local actions are likely to matter more than broad culls along the coast.

What About the Orcas?

One of the strongest arguments for culls has involved killer whales, not just salmon. The endangered Southern Resident orcas of the Salish Sea feed mainly on Chinook salmon. In British Columbia, the Pacific Balance Pinniped Society has argued that halving seal numbers would leave more salmon for the orcas.

The new study does not model the orcas directly, but its logic applies. If fewer seals and sea lions do not mean more Chinook, then culling them would not feed the orcas either. Some conservation scientists also point out that Chinook make up only a small share of seal and sea lion diets, which limits how much a cull could change.

The orcas' food supply depends far more on the overall abundance of Chinook salmon. That brings the debate back to habitat, dams, hatcheries and fishing, the factors that shape how many salmon survive in the first place.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do seals and sea lions eat salmon? Yes. But they also eat fish such as Pacific hake, which eat young salmon or compete with them. That is why removing the mammals can backfire.

Did researchers actually cull animals for this study? No. It is a computer model of the ocean food web off Northern California, Oregon and Washington. Its predictions have not been tested in the field.

Does this mean removing sea lions never helps salmon? Not quite. The study and its release note that targeted removals at bottlenecks, such as dams, can help local fish runs. The finding applies to widespread, population-level culls.

Which salmon did the study look at? Chinook and coho salmon, the species at the centre of many recovery efforts on the U.S. West Coast.

Who carried out the research? Scientists from NOAA Fisheries and Oregon State University, led by Dylan Gomes. The paper was published in Science on 19 November 2026.

© 2026 NatureWorldNews.com All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

Read Entire Article

         

        

Start the new Vibrations with a Medbed Franchise today!  

Protect your whole family with Quantum Orgo-Life® devices

  Advertising by Adpathway