Cook County prosecutors dropped charges in an alleged arson and insurance fraud scheme connected to the 2023 fire that killed Chicago Firefighter Jermaine Pelt

CHICAGO — Cook County prosecutors have dropped charges against two men who had been accused of setting an abandoned building on fire tied to an alleged insurance fraud scheme that led to the death of a Chicago firefighter.

Anthony Moore, 49, and Nicholas Virgil, 39, had faced multiple charges in connection with the April 4, 2023, fire that killed Chicago Firefighter Jermaine Pelt in the line of duty.

The trial for Moore and Virgil was scheduled to begin June 15, but Cook County prosecutors dropped all charges last week, CBS Chicago reported. Their public defenders had argued the case against them was weak.

Prosecutors said the case remains “active and ongoing” despite the dropped charges. Virgil had faced multiple felony counts, including murder and aggravated arson, while Moore had been indicted on wire fraud, insurance fraud, forgery and other charges.

In 2024, Virgil, Moore and Martez Cristler, 24, were charged in connection with Pelt’s death. Cristler, who faced murder and aggravated arson charges, had his case dismissed months later.

In a statement, the Chicago Fire Department said it remains committed to seeking accountability and justice in the case.

“We believe those responsible must be held fully accountable for their actions. We trust that the Cook County State’s Attorney’s Office will pursue this case with the diligence and determination it deserves and take every appropriate step to ensure justice is served. The Fire Department stands ready to provide any assistance necessary to support the successful prosecution of those responsible.”

Because there is no statute of limitations for murder in Illinois, prosecutors could refile charges in the future if they determine there is sufficient evidence to prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt.

Funding will support emergency response capabilities and emergency operations centers nationwide

June 15, 2026 07:01 PM

 · 

Searsmont Assistant Fire Chief Wayne Woodbury died from injuries sustained in the Robbins Lumber fire and explosion

June 15, 2026 08:23 AM

 · 

Three Philadelphia police officers were wounded during a confrontation with a retired firefighter before officers returned fire

Seattle’s fire department used artificial intelligence for more than two years to analyze medical 911 calls raising questions about transparency, privacy and oversight