PROTECT YOUR DNA WITH QUANTUM TECHNOLOGY
Orgo-Life the new way to the future Advertising by AdpathwayCitation: Burin G (2026) Migration as a key influence on ungulate eco-evolutionary history. PLoS Biol 24(11): e3004115. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3004115
Published: November 18, 2026
Copyright: © 2026 Gustavo Burin. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Funding: GB was funded by the European Union’s Horizon research and innovation programme under the Marie Sklodowska-Curie grant CAUSATION (Grant Agreement ID: 101150734). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The author has declared that no competing interests exist.
Migratory behaviour is present in many groups within vertebrates, marine (fish, whales), and terrestrial (birds, ruminants) alike. This behaviour allows species to overcome locally unfavourable conditions such as changes in temperature, water, food, and mating partner availability, which can provide short-term benefits for the individuals and populations [1]. However, the consequences of migration over longer timescales are less clear: while species that can accurately track the changes in environmental/biological resources might benefit from migration by potentially decreasing extinction rates, failing to accurately track resources can lead to an increase in the extinction probability, due to food shortage, increased predation while migrating, and mismatches with environment conditions. Moreover, local extirpations, such as can happen when migrations collapse, could break up contiguous species ranges into isolated populations, potentially fostering new species if gene flow is interrupted [2]. Therefore, migration can have a very important role in affecting the diversification dynamics of groups reliant on this behaviour for their population dynamics.
Due to its very nature, migration can be affected and even disrupted by many biotic and abiotic factors. Anthropogenic activities such as the construction of roads, or climatic changes induced by human activity, can disrupt the migratory routes of some species, perhaps leading to local extirpations and, if sustained, even extinctions. However, these disruptions may represent just an intensification of long-term trends. These trends need to be assessed to provide the full picture of how migratory behaviour might change the diversification rates of certain groups. To better understand the consequences of migrations on the macroevolutionary dynamics of lineages, a recent study published in PLOS Biology by Abraham and colleagues [3] assessed the effects of migratory behaviour on the speciation and extinction rates of ungulates, a charismatic and ecologically important group of mammals. By using trait-dependent speciation and extinction models, the authors found that, per their expectations, migratory ungulate species indeed show higher extinction rates when compared to nonmigratory species. This pattern was highlighted by the inclusion of species that were recently extinct (i.e., within the Quaternary), which also allowed the authors to alleviate some of the consequences of methodological limitations known for these models. Furthermore, this increased extinction is coupled with high speciation rates in migratory species. The authors speculate that this might result from the isolation of populations that diverge genetically from the remaining populations of the same species, and hence resulting in a high turnover of species showing this behaviour.
Another key result from the paper was that the increased extinction rates were associated with a decrease in the total volume of the ecomorphospace (a form of representation in which each point represents the combination of different characteristics of a given species) occupied by ungulates, due particularly to the loss of migratory species, which were more prevalent amongst recently extinct species than amongst contemporary species. This decrease is more pronounced in the African fauna. This result suggests that the loss of species with unique combinations of characteristics not observed in the surviving lineages might have unevenly impacted the ecosystems, perhaps leading to pervasive and irreversible changes in the places where the losses of migratory species were most pronounced.
Diversification models, and more specifically trait-dependent diversification models such as the ones used in the study, have been under strong scrutiny for the past decade [4,5]. Part of the criticism is related to the use of indirect information to estimate extinction rates when using phylogenies that only include extant species. This incomplete representation of species would render any rate estimates inaccurate at best, with some authors going even further by saying that no rate can be directly estimated [6]. While the debate is ongoing, by including recently extinct species in their analyses, Abraham and colleagues were able to more reliably estimate the extinction rates, which is key to their findings and also shows that their inclusion can help us further understand not only the diversification dynamics but also the ecological consequences of the extinctions (either natural or human-related). Moreover, it allowed the authors to identify which characteristics were shared by the species that were affected the most by the recent extinctions (such as being large-bodied, for example), which may help understand the consequences of species loss.
The ability to track resources is a key component of the migratory behaviour. Species can benefit from moving to areas with more favourable conditions (Fig 1A), but if they mistime this movement, it might mean the demise of entire populations (Fig 1B). Over long timescales, this duality is also reflected in the high turnover of ungulate species caused by the combination of high speciation and extinction rates (Fig 1B and 1C). Lineages with high turnover tend to be more susceptible to stochastic, short-term variations in the conditions to which they are subjected [7], due to the fact that most of the many lineages that are generated are also short-lived. In times of global environmental changes, mostly human-induced, this ephemerality might be even more crucial in determining the fate of migratory species. The ongoing changes in phenology (e.g., [8]) and landscapes (e.g., [9]), among others, will likely intensify the effects of migration in the diversification dynamics of the group, rendering them even more vulnerable to these changes.
Fig 1. Schematic representation of macroevolutionary dynamics of migratory species.
In all panels, filled silhouettes represent available or established resources and populations, respectively. Solid arrows represent successful migration, whereas dashed arrows indicate populations that migrated but failed to establish in the new areas, reinforced by the red crosses. (A) If populations of a species are able to track resources in time and space, this likely leads to low extinction rates. (B) However, if populations fail to accurately track the resources, they are more likely to die out, leading to the eventual extinction of the species. (C) If the migration is partially successful, but some populations are locally extinct, this might lead to the isolation of different populations, and, with enough local adaptations without gene flow, this might lead to the emergence of new species (orange silhouettes), increasing speciation rates. (Wildebeest silhouettes obtained from phylopic.org—Graham Montgomery under CC 4.0).
Even though the temporal scales are very different, understanding the deep time dynamics of species gain and loss might help us better understand (and maybe forecast) the possible consequences of current environmental changes. The results shown by Abraham and colleagues showcase how much we can gain by integrating information from both extant and extinct species to shed light on long-term diversification dynamics whilst also capturing the recent, likely human-induced effects that may intensify trends. They also highlight which species might be facing stronger pressures, which may foster new conservation studies and policies focussing on protecting not only migratory ungulates, but also other migratory species [10]. Taken together, the results contribute to a growing body of research that combines extant and extinct species to more accurately trace recent and deep time eco-evolutionary dynamics of organisms.






















English (US) ·
French (CA) ·